LEARN · EXPLAIN · REVISE

Can E(X)=2 and E(X²)=3 hold? Prove or refute.

Read the idea, work independently, then explain what changed.

Return to the lesson / paper ↗

高三選擇性必修第三册(A版).pdf · 7.3 · PDF 67 / printed page 62

Revisit first: Conditions, partitions and posterior probability

TOPIC 01

Distribution means, variances and dependence

Compute weighted moments and apply shifts/scales with correct units and dependence conditions.

What you will be able to explain

Compute weighted moments and apply shifts/scales with correct units and dependence conditions.
Use nonnegative variance to reject impossible summaries and compare equal-mean distributions.

Try it. Leave your reasoning visible.

Use one hint at a time. A correction explains what changed, not just the final answer.

Examples 1–3: study a full demonstration; finish a solution from its first step; then choose a method independently before opening the solution. The remaining exercises may continue after class.

01 / Transfer#Your turn

Can E(X)=2 and E(X²)=3 hold? Prove or refute.

E(X)=2;\ E(X^2)=3

Finite-distribution probabilities must be nonnegative and sum to one; dependence is only as explicitly stated.

Skills and prerequisite lessons

Scope: School extension · This task develops the school textbook skill beyond the explicitly listed JAE syllabus topics.

Working and explanation

BUILD THE REASONING

Hint 1

Use nonnegativity of variance as a feasibility condition.

Hint 2

Start from this intermediate relation.

\operatorname{Var}(X)=3-2^2=-1

Worked solution

Use nonnegativity of variance as a feasibility condition.
Establish and simplify this mathematical relation.
$\operatorname{Var}(X)=3-2^2=-1$
Establish and simplify this mathematical relation.
$\operatorname{Var}(X)\ge0$
Moment summaries must satisfy structural constraints, not only look plausible separately.

No; the implied variance is −1.

Checks and common pitfalls: Moment summaries must satisfy structural constraints, not only look plausible separately.

Reasoning checklist · self / teacher assessment

Use nonnegativity of variance as a feasibility condition.
Give the intermediate relations and explain the conclusion with its restrictions.
Moment summaries must satisfy structural constraints, not only look plausible separately.

Think first. Reveal a hint when the class is ready.

Teacher preparation and assessment

40-minute lesson

Minutes	Focus	Teaching and student action
5	Predict	Predict what happens to variance after multiplying all values by −2 and adding 7.
8	Build the idea	Sample response: shift does not affect spread; the scale squares to four.
10	Guided comparison	Sample response: X+1−X=1, so the sum has variance zero.
12	Independent practice and discussion	Compare equal-mean games and audit proposed moments for feasibility.
5	Exit and next step	Exit: distinguish E(X²) from E(X)² and state the independence requirement for adding variances.

Question sequence

Predict what happens to variance after multiplying all values by −2 and adding 7.
Sample response: X+1−X=1, so the sum has variance zero.

Board development

Average first, center before measuring spread
$E(X)=\sum xp_x;\ \operatorname{Var}(X)=E(X^2)-E(X)^2$

Expected correct and incorrect responses

Correct sample: 1
Anticipated wrong response: 2 — Uses the second raw moment without centering.
Anticipated wrong response: 11 — Scales variance linearly and adds a constant shift.
Using unweighted means for unequal probabilities.
Adding variances without checking covariance.

Follow-up questions

Follow-up: Center before squaring or subtract the squared mean from the second moment. Then explain why 2 fails.
Follow-up: Square the scale and remove the constant shift. Then explain why 11 fails.
Explain why a negative scale reverses positions but does not make variance negative.

Remediation

Sample response: shift does not affect spread; the scale squares to four.
Return to the first example, identify the missing condition, then solve one fresh task without viewing its solution.

Exit check

Exit: distinguish E(X²) from E(X)² and state the independence requirement for adding variances.

Assessment checklist and sample responses

Representation and conditions
For probabilities 3/4,1/4 on 0,2, E(X)=0·3/4+2·1/4=1/2.
Connected mathematical reasoning
For fair 0,2, the mean is 1 and both squared deviations are 1, so variance is 1.
Interpretation and boundary check
If Y=1−X, X+Y=1 and variance is zero; independence is false.