Can changing one endpoint create a gap or two different outputs?
My prediction and reason
For the rental rule, predict the charge at exactly 1 hour before testing values just below and above 1. Decide which branch contains the boundary.
Evidence and observations
For 0 < t ≤ 1 charge 6; for 1 < t ≤ 4 charge 6 + 4(t − 1). Record the branch and charge at t = 0.8, 1, 1.01 and 2.5.
Change both inequalities at t = 1 to strict inequalities. Record which input loses its output and restore the original coverage.
Let both rental branches include t = 1, then do the same for h(x) = x + 2 for x < 0 and x² for x ≥ 0. Compare the two formulas at each overlap.
Explain or give a counterexample
Transfer
A rule uses x + 1 for x ≤ 2 and 3 for x ≥ 2. Does the overlap invalidate the function? What changes if the second formula becomes 4?
Exit task
A rule gives x + 1 for x ≤ 2 and 3 for x ≥ 2. Is it a function, and what is its value at 2?
5 min predict the one-hour charge; 12 min change endpoints; 8 min distinguish overlap from output conflict; 12 min paper evaluation; 3 min exit check.
Can changing one endpoint create a gap or two different outputs?
For the rental rule, predict the charge at exactly 1 hour before testing values just below and above 1. Decide which branch contains the boundary.
Evidence tasks
- For 0 < t ≤ 1 charge 6; for 1 < t ≤ 4 charge 6 + 4(t − 1). Record the branch and charge at t = 0.8, 1, 1.01 and 2.5.
- Change both inequalities at t = 1 to strict inequalities. Record which input loses its output and restore the original coverage.
- Let both rental branches include t = 1, then do the same for h(x) = x + 2 for x < 0 and x² for x ≥ 0. Compare the two formulas at each overlap.
Reference reasoning
Evaluate an input using a branch whose condition contains it. A missing boundary produces a gap only if that input is intended to be in the domain. Overlap is compatible with a function when all applicable branches give the same value: both rental formulas give 6 at t = 1. If overlapping branches give different values, uniqueness fails; at x = 0 the formulas x + 2 and x² give 2 and 0. A jump in a graph is allowed in a function; two different outputs for one input are not.
Find the rental charges at 0.8 and 2.5 hours.
f(t)={6,6+4(t−1),0<t≤1,1<t≤4. - 0.8 is in the first branch, so f(0.8) = 6.
- 2.5 is in the second branch, so f(2.5) = 6 + 4(2.5 − 1) = 12.
Evaluate at a negative input and at the boundary.
h(x)={x+2,x2,x<0,x≥0;h(−1), h(0) - Since −1 < 0, h(−1) = −1 + 2 = 1.
- Equality belongs to the second branch, so h(0) = 0² = 0.
Transfer and exit task
A rule uses x + 1 for x ≤ 2 and 3 for x ≥ 2. Does the overlap invalidate the function? What changes if the second formula becomes 4?
A rule gives x + 1 for x ≤ 2 and 3 for x ≥ 2. Is it a function, and what is its value at 2?
Yes. At the only overlap x = 2, both branches give 3, so there is one distinct output; f(2) = 3.
- Checks both formulas at the overlap.
- Explains uniqueness through equal values rather than declaring every overlap invalid.
Questions
- Which inequality includes equality at this input?
- Do two applicable formulas necessarily mean two distinct outputs?
Expected responses
- Students may use the second rental formula at all times. Ask them to label the branch first.
- Some call any jump or overlap invalid. Separate coverage, distinct outputs and continuity.
Confusions
- Do not include t = 0 or t > 4 in the rental example without changing its stated domain.
- For h at 0, the original condition selects x² even though the other formula has a different limiting value.
Board plan
- Input → branch condition → substitution.
- Boundary check: coverage and one distinct output.
- Equal overlap may be valid; a jump may also be valid.